Yarmouth, Massachusetts, is one of Cape Cod’s top vacation destinations, thanks to its access to beaches on Cape Cod Bay, Lewis Bay, and Nantucket Sound, bustling downtown, and proximity to Hyannis Harbor. The community also has an emerging dining scene, with most of its high-end restaurants enjoying prime locations on Main Street in South Yarmouth and West Yarmouth.
While you’ll never find yourself short on places to visit for dinner, lunchtime dining is equally as impressive. As you wander this community with about 23,000 permanent residents, you’ll come across multiple sub and sandwich shops offering unique takes on these afternoon staples.
Here’s a look at the top five sub and sandwich shops to try in Yarmouth during your Cape Cod vacation.
1) Timmy’s Roast Beef
When seeking a pure sandwich shop, few places on the Cape beat Timmy’s Roast Beef in West Yarmouth. This restaurant specializes in sandwiches, and you’ll see why it’s so popular from the second you walk through the front doors.
As its name suggests, Timmy’s Roast Beef offers a wide selection of roast beef sandwiches, including the massive Mega Roast Beef. They also serve pastrami, chicken, turkey, and grilled cheese sandwiches, and you can upgrade your selection to come with fries and a drink.
There are subs available at Timmy’s Roast Beef, too, including options like roast beef, veal parmesan, chicken parmesan, homemade meatball, and eggplant. And if you aren’t in the mood for a sandwich, items like chicken fingers, hot wings, mozzarella sticks, pizza rolls, onion rings, and fried green beans are also on the menu.
2) Piccadilly Cafe & Deli
In South Yarmouth, across Main Street from Yarmouth Crossing, is Piccadilly Cafe & Deli, a diner-style establishment serving some of Cape Cod’s best sandwiches. Piccadilly Cafe & Deli is only open between 6:00 AM and 2:00 PM, though, so you’ll have to come around lunchtime if you want to give them a try.
Some of the most popular sandwiches on the Piccadilly Cafe & Deli menu include hot options like the chicken parmesan, open roast turkey, BBQ chicken filet, filet of fish, and French dip.
They also serve their Cape Cod Reuben, which comes with Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and haddock instead of corned beef, and have various cold sandwiches like pastrami, corned beef, baked ham, and veggie. You can choose between white, light rye, or marble bread with your selection, or get the sandwich on a roll or bagel.
3) Carluccio’s Italian Deli & Pizzeria
For a uniquely Italian experience in South Yarmouth, Carluccio’s Italian Deli & Pizzeria is worth a visit. Most menu items at this restaurant are made with ingredients imported from Italy, providing the opportunity to sample authentic Italian cuisine without leaving the Cape.
There’s an incredible selection of sandwiches at Carluccio’s, starting with the hot offerings. These options include classic Italian, meatball, sausage and pepper, mozzarella and tomato, chicken cutlet, eggplant parmesan, roast beef, and turkey. You can also get these combinations as a calzone.
Carluccio’s has also created a series of one-of-a-kind cold deli-style sandwiches you won’t find anywhere else. These sandwiches include The Plymouth Rock, New York State of Mind, Marco Polo, Cosimo’s Special, the Venezia, and the Calabria Combo. The ingredients on these sandwiches, including ham, pastrami, pepperoni, prosciuttini, genoa, salami, and various cheeses, come from Boar’s Head Provision Company.
4) Yarmouth Pizza By Evan
Most restaurants on this list are in South Yarmouth or West Yarmouth, with the lone exception being Yarmouth Pizza by Evan on Route 6A in Yarmouth Port. This restaurant is open for lunch and dinner all year-round and offers some of the best subs you’ll find anywhere on the Cape, in addition to its tasty pizzas.
The hot sub options at Yarmouth Pizza By Evan include meatball, hamburger, chicken fajita, grilled chicken, buffalo chicken, chicken cutlet, and eggplant parmesan. You can choose between small or large subs or get your meal as a wrap if you’re looking for something other than bread.
They have a selection of cold subs, too, including roast beef, ham, Italian, genoa, tuna, BLT, and turkey breast, and you can also grab these items as a wrap.
If you’re looking for lunch on the north end of Yarmouth, Pizza By Evan is worth a stop.
5) JoMama’s NY Bagels & Coffeehouse
A final spot you might want to visit for a sub or sandwich in South Yarmouth is JoMama’s NY Bagels & Coffeehouse, a shop specializing in coffee and bagels that also carries a decent selection of sandwiches.
Hot sandwiches available at JoMama’s NY Bagels & Coffeehouse include The Kickin Chicken, El Diablo, The ABC, and The Cuban. They also have a veggie sandwich and a Reuben.
For cold sandwiches, you’ll find options like The Godfather, The Tom & Berry, The Italian Job, the Buffalo Solider Wrap, and chicken salad. They have a hummus and feta wrap and a tuna salad, too.
Or, if you’d prefer, you can create a sandwich all your own using the restaurant’s ingredients. You’ll pay per item, but the sky is the limit when you go this route.
Find Your Lunch Spot in Yarmouth
You can make whatever you wish of your Yarmouth vacation, as the community has plenty of spots to keep you busy. At lunchtime, you’ll also find multiple outstanding sandwich shops, cafes, and restaurants that provide the perfect place to eat away from your vacation rental.
You’ll undoubtedly be busy while exploring the Cape, so it’ll make a lot of sense to eat your lunches close to the beach or attraction you’re visiting. For that reason, these sub and sandwich shops in Yarmouth could become integral parts of your vacation.
